This is the image of the day. No, the image of the year, surely. Maybe of the decade. I find it magnificent. Wondrous. Humbling. And yes, I admit it. Moving.
This is of course the first ever image of a black hole. Its mass is 6.5 billion times that of our sun. It is about 54 million light years away, at the heart of the galaxy known as Messier (M) 87.
I’ve no hesitation in saying that this image, redolent of a doughnut, will prove to be as emblematic as that famous photo of the earth rising above the surface of the moon. (That and other famous astronomical images are here, thanks to the Guardian.) There are some photos you know you’ll never forget, because they burn themselves into the memory and the imagination. This is one of them.
As a milestone in scientific collaboration, this image is already a spectacular achievement. It is the result of networking eight radio telescopes across the world into what’s been called the Event Horizon Telescope (EHT). The effect is to create a receptor dish as large as the earth itself with a vastly increased reach into space. It’s an amazing feat of technology in its own right, not to mention the extent of partnership and team working among all the research agencies involved. When human beings pool their knowledge and their talents, there seem to be no limits to what can be done.
As for this ring of fire, I think it would need a poet to do it justice. As we know, black holes can’t themselves be seen directly since all electromagnetic radiation, including visible light, is pulled back inside these super-massive objects by their immense gravitational fields. What we are looking at is the event-horizon, the fiery perimeter-zone where matter in the “accretion disc” is being sucked inside the black hole at nearly the speed of light and generating such prodigious quantities of energy that it becomes visible in its last gasp.
So as the name implies, black holes will always be deeply mysterious. Astrophysicists refer to them as singularities where the “normal” laws of physics break down. Beyond the event horizon is unknowable, so distorted is the space-time continuum by the massive gravitational effects of black holes. But what we do know is that these objects power the galaxies they lie at the heart of. That includes our own galaxy, the Milky Way. We can look forward to seeing “our own” black hole, Sagittarius A*, in due course, thanks to the EHT.
We owe a great deal of the theory of black holes to Stephen Hawking, especially what happens around the event horizon. It’s a tribute to his extraordinary mind that observation is on the point of confirming his theoretical models. It may possibly refine them too: falsifiability is a key concept in establishing sound scientific hypotheses. But behind him stands another of the twentieth century’s greatest scientists, Albert Einstein. His theory of general relativity will also be tested by these latest revelations. Relativity theory was itself a refinement of Newtonian physics whose accuracy failed near extremities and singularities like very massive objects. Will his theories too need further modification in the light of the research that will follow this image of a black hole?
What we need to remember is the key role that is played in science by the imagination. The periodic table, the Benzene ring and the structure of the double helix in DNA are all attributable as much to the imaginative capacity to think in new ways that break out of the boundaries of accepted models as to observation by itself. The black hole was imagined long before it was theorised about let alone observed in its own right, as has been this year.
Which is where the arts can perhaps add their commentary on this dazzling image. I saw two allusions in it that have stayed with me this afternoon. The first is a poem by the seventeenth century metaphysical poet Henry Vaughan:
I saw eternity the other night,
Like a great ring of pure and endless light,
All calm as it was bright,
And round beneath it, Time in hours, days, years
Drive’n by the spheres
Like a vast shadow moved; in which the world
And all her train were hurl’d.
“Calm” a black hole is not. It is a vortex of furious uncontained violence. And yet from half way across the cosmos, it radiates a sense of timeless stability. The perception gets me thinking about time, eternity and God, what is transient, what is enduring, where we came from and where we are bound on this little speck of stardust we call Earth. Spirituality comes into things when we look up at the heavens and read how they “declare the glory of God” (Psalm 19.1).
The other allusion is to Wagner’s cycle of four music dramas The Ring. Here the connotations are altogether darker, more true perhaps to the catastrophic forces of a black hole. The ring is a symbol of naked power, stolen from its rightful owners the Rhine Maidens and thereafter destroying everyone, god or mortal, whom it touches. (Cross reference J. R. R. Tolkein’s Lord of the Rings where many of these themes recur.) In the final scene of the fourth drama, The Twilight of the Gods, the ring is returned to the Rhine, the old corrupted world is destroyed and out of fire and water a new, redeemed order rises up. Black holes, conjectures Hawking, play a vital part in “recycling” the matter of the universe which, if you think about it, is a redemptive image. Wagnerian in its scope, you might say.
I began by saying that I was humbled by this image of a black hole. It put me in my place, and put my worries and concerns into a larger context. It’s not that they don’t matter any more, simply that when we look beyond ourselves and contemplate the wonders of the cosmos, it has a curiously calming, healing effect. To me, that makes this iconic image religious in character. And that should drive us to our knees.
Reveries and Reflections from Northumberland
About Me
- Aquilonius
- Pilgrim, priest and ponderer. European living in North East England. Retired parish priest, theological educator, cathedral precentor and dean.
Showing posts with label Einstein. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Einstein. Show all posts
Wednesday, 10 April 2019
Friday, 14 December 2018
Mary: an Advent Meditation
About suffering they were never wrong,The Old Masters: how well they understood
Its human position: how it takes place
While someone else is eating or opening a window or just walking dully along.
I had to study that poem at school. It was my first introduction to any great twentieth century poet. I've never forgotten it. Auden takes Breughel's painting The Fall
of Icarus as an example: the ploughman carries on ploughing, and the ship
that has somewhere to get to sails calmly on; and all this while a boy falls
catastrophically out of the sky. Disaster strikes: someone you love dies, or you
are diagnosed as being terminally ill, or your marriage breaks up, or you lose
your job. And you wonder how, just outside your universe that is
disintegrating, another, ordinary world just carries on uncaring, oblivious.
But
about ecstasy the artists and poets are never wrong either, and it is the same
truth. You are in the seventh heaven, surprised by joy: you fall in love, or
find a new friendship, or have a child, or meet God. And not far away, the rest
of the human race is not aware of you, still less cares about what for you is
making creation sing. It is as if in both agony and ecstasy, time is
attenuated, given a new quality, seems to stand still. Einstein's theory of relativity talks about dilation when space-time is distorted close to the speed of light. It takes on a new quality. But everybody else's
"ordinary" time just carries on as it always has. In a sense, it's as if we are living in
different worlds until the ecstasy subsides or the agony begins to be healed,
and the extraordinary merges with the ordinary once more.
Paintings
and sculptures of the Annunciation often depict this double world. Inside her house, the
Virgin Mary is rapt in contemplation, heaven reflected in her face as she is
overwhelmed by the power of the Most High that has come from beyond the
farthest star to visit her. On the other side of the window sheep are grazing,
people buy and sell in the streets of a town, a farmer gathers his harvest. Something of this is what I see hinted at in Josef Pyrz' sculpture of the Annunciation in Durham Cathedral's Galilee Chapel. Rapture, toughness, acceptance, pain even are written into her face and body in a physical, tactile way. I used to encourage visitors to caress the sculpture to gain a sense of the complex emotional and spiritual power of this marvellous piece.
Outside the window footsteps fall
Into the ordinary dayAnd with the sun along the wall
Pursue their unreturning way.
Sound's perpetual roundabout
Rolls its numbered octaves out
And hoarsely grinds its battered tune.
But through the endless afternoon
These neither speak nor movement make,But stare into their deepening trance
As if their gaze would never break.
Beauty
and tragedy are the soil in which contemplatives are made. Mary knew both:
beauty her encounter with the angel of the Annunciation; tragedy in the sword
that pierced her heart as she gazed on her Son at Golgotha .
But it needed more than beauty or tragedy to make her the one we honour as Theotokos the God-bearer. Many people
experience beauty and tragedy but are none the wiser for it. Their souls are
not enriched, their capacity for contemplation is not deepened. What then was
Mary's secret?
I think it was her gift for openness to the new thing that God was doing. Words
like sensitivity and awareness come to mind, the gift of realising that the world is, as they say on Lindisfarne, a thin place, and
that on the other side of that almost transparent membrane lies another realm,
the realm of the spiritual, the heavenly, the transcendent. You see into the life of things, to quote Wordsworth. It is what Moses
turned aside to see in the blazing bush and what Elijah heard in the still
small voice, and what Mother Julian of Norwich
understood in the hazel-nut she held in her hand that, she said, only existed because God loved it. And what the mystics down the
centuries teach us is that ordinary life can become transparent, if we learn to
see it in a new way, train our faculties of sensitivity and awareness in order
to discover the world as a sacrament. After all, that is precisely what we do
each Sunday at the eucharist, when we take ordinary things and find them to be
divine. Lesser annunciations, you might say, are waiting to
happen all around us, waiting to show us the new thing that God wants to do in
our lives.
And
what about us? God wants us, I think, to become like Mary: each of
us a theotokos,
a bearer of God to others. Outside Salisbury Cathedral is a statue of Mary
by Elizabeth Frink. It depicts her walking vigorously away from the Cathedral,
not because she doesn't like the worship there, but because she is taking the good
news to the world. This is the Walking Madonna, the Mary of the Magnificat whose contemplative vision
has turned her into a woman of action who is passionate for justice, for a world where wrong is
righted, the hungry fed and the downtrodden exalted.
Whatever annunciations we are given, whatever angel we glimpse when time stands still, whether it is tragedy
or joyous rapture, agony or ecstasy, there is call to be obeyed. Behold the servant of
the Lord: let it be to me according to thy word. So that when the time comes for
the angel to depart from us, and we return to our ordinary days, it will be
with God conceived, so to speak, within us, so that we can lovingly bear him and bring him forth
to a world that longs to be happy and that needs him so much.
Ave Maria, gratia plena
Hail Mary, full of grace, the Lord is with you. Blessed are you, and blessed is the fruit of your womb Jesus. Holy Mary, Mother of God, pray for us sinners now and at the hour of our death.
Ave Maria, gratia plena
Hail Mary, full of grace, the Lord is with you. Blessed are you, and blessed is the fruit of your womb Jesus. Holy Mary, Mother of God, pray for us sinners now and at the hour of our death.
Friday, 2 June 2017
A Cruise on the Rhine Part 2
Saturday
We are on the move all night. We wake up to an industrial landscape. Saturday is a working day in Germany so there is a lot of activity on the banks and a lot of freight traffic on the river. This is Mannheim. Not the sort of place you'd come to for a city break, but convenient for today's first port of call, Heidelberg. The hills of the Rhine Gorge have receded. This is more like the Danube.
For this is a tourism honey-pot, one of those places where everybody, just
everybody, has to come. And I look for all the world like a tourist with my
earpiece, my camera and my slightly helpless look. It's true that I don't
follow my camera around on the end of a stick like some. But I do stop to take all
the classic shots of this ancient city: the castle, views down to the town
therefrom, the bridge, the church onion domes, the
quaint cobbled streets. If I were borrowing from the travel-writer's lexicon I
would wax eloquent about this "iconic" place, this little city that
"nestles" on the banks of the Neckar, its "vibrant" street
life and so on. Yet I do fall for the photographic
clichés, all of them. I hate myself at the very moment I'm committing these
outrages against cultural courtesy. It would take a Patrick Leigh Fermor to
cure me of it.
We meet the boat at Speyer, another city
I've longed to visit for decades. It doesn't disappoint. After lunch we walk to
the Cathedral. It's an immense Romanesque building, very grand, very pure, very
disciplined and very pink (in sandstone). If there
are later architectural additions to this grand church begun in 1030, they
don't draw attention to themselves. It is said to be
highly restored, but it is lovingly done. Maybe it’s as fine as Durham?
I entertain that impious thought, allow myself to ponder. It's unthinkable to say so, and yet... The way the spaces interlock - nave, aisles, transepts,
baptistery, presbytery, an immensely high sanctuary - it works with a
harmoniousness I can't recall seeing in any other Romanesque church. Conques
maybe? Paray-Le-Moniale? It's hard to say. But this church moves me deeply, even from our first sight of it above the
trees, and I wonder why.

J goes back to the ship while I seek out
the Technik-Museum Speyer. We have seen it as we arrive on the coach: a
Lufthansa Boeing 747 suspend d High above an extraordinary array of aircraft,
ships, road vehicles and railway engines laid out on
a big campus that surrounds the exhibition galleries. It is worth the €16 I pay
(and that fee doesn't include the iMax cinema which shows films on a variety of
transport and space travel themes). I enjoy the trains best of all, of course, such as the huge beautifully engineered
2-10-0 locomotives built for the Deutsche Reichsbahn during the 1940s. But
there are lots of other machines to relish as well: vintage cars, U-boats, buses, emergency vehicles
and ships. I suppose the highlight has to be climbing
up to the 747 where you can view the aircraft at the closest possible range,
and get inside it (where sections of fascia have been removed so you can
see how the fuselage is constructed). You can even walk out on the wing, a giddying experience if you make the mistake of looking
down.
We leave a river valley and climb up to
the plateau on which sits Freudenstadt, one of the
larger communes in the North of the Forest. It sits at an altitude of over 700
metres which means it's the same height as Cross Fell or the Cheviot. We are to
spend an hour here. This may prove quite a challenge as there is not much to
see other than an immense market place (the largest
in Germany) and the Lutheran church that is positioned at one corner. As we go
in, the afternoon service is ending. The congregation is singing Nun Danket Alle Gott. So we have got to church on Sunday after all. The town has an interesting but sad story. Towards the end
of the war, French partisans burned it down in revenge for the destruction of
Haguenau by the Germans. So,
very little of Freudenstadt is original. The church burned too, but has been
well restored. The town is lively with locals enjoying their sunny weekend. Apart from cafes, no shops are open. The first day of the
week is for recreation, family, churchgoing.
We drive off the plateau down a
spectacular road whose hairpin bends cause a few intakes of breath. Near the
mouth of the valley, we stop at a hotel for Black Forest Gateau of which much
has been made all day. It's in a beautiful setting. But all the clichés are there: cuckoo clocks, maids in peasant costume,
overhanging roofs, the celebrated gateau, and even cowbells in a
nearby field which I'm sure are not serendipitous but laid on for the enjoyment
of tourists greedy for every experience that matches their "Germany" of the imagination. It feels like a parody of
itself, playing unashamedly to the tourist market of which I am an involuntary
(or voluntary) part. I have another of those "I hate this" moments.
And yet this is just such a place, in a more innocent era, where my parents could have come all those years ago. I'll
assign it to the memory I've been toying with all day and imagine that this was
the locus, edit out all nonsense and recreate a mental image of how it must
once have been.
We are on the move all night. We wake up to an industrial landscape. Saturday is a working day in Germany so there is a lot of activity on the banks and a lot of freight traffic on the river. This is Mannheim. Not the sort of place you'd come to for a city break, but convenient for today's first port of call, Heidelberg. The hills of the Rhine Gorge have receded. This is more like the Danube.
I've always wanted to come to
Heidelberg. The medieval town sits where the Neckar
flows out of the hills into the floodplain of the Rhine. It's such a musical
name for a river, I've always thought so: maybe that's because it
features in one of the most beautiful books I've ever read, Reunion by Fred Uhlmann. My mother gave
it to me as a teenager. It's about the relationship between a Jewish and an Aryan boy in the
1930s. Their friendship blossoms in the valley of the Neckar and the rolling
landscapes of Baden-Württemberg. If there is one book I'd love to have written
it's this, barely 10000 words long but what words!
The coach winds up Heidelberg's steep
narrow streets to the Schloss at the top. We affix our portable radio gadgets
to our left ears and step off, our guide is a feisty woman who cracks lewd
jokes in her broken English. She wears a funny helmet
like a Great War soldier in the trenches, festooned with hundreds of badges.
This distinctiveness is helpful in the crowds. She
evidently knows her stuff.
The Neckar is about the same width here
as the South Tyne at Haydon Bridge. It too has an
elegant seven-arched bridge with hills rising steeply on either side. And both
places begin with the same letter. This is helpful in explaining to our
fellow-cruisers the topography of home.
You aren't shown much of the Castle interior. Some of it is ruinous anyway. But what survives
is very splendid. We mark the occasion by having a group photograph taken in
the courtyard. We all grin dutifully. Some people pay €8 for a print. We don’t.
Our only entrance inside the Schloss is
to a vaulted room where there are two enormous wine vats, a Big One and an
Extremely Big One. You can clamber up staircases and over the top of the EBO. This of course is what tourists love.
Cameras flash in their hundreds as they try to capture the scene (which is very
hard to do as it is so dark inside). The trick then is to fall for buying a
drink at the strategically placed counters. As it is
so early (about ten o'clock), no one in our group succumbs to this temptation;
anyway, our guide wouldn't
stand for a moment's delay in her rigorous schedule that is timed to the last
second.
We descend from this acropolis in a funicular, then fight our way through the streets. We visit the Heiligen
Geist Kirche, a remarkably lovely gothic church in
the MarktPlatz. I am struck by a window in red near the entrance. It is known
as the Physics Window. It quotes Einstein's energy equation and the date 6 August 1945, the bombing of Hiroshima. The text speaks about
science can equip humanity for both good and evil. In
a university city this seems apt.
The best part of the Cathedral is its
crypt. "The best crypt in the world" someone has written. It is vast,
consisting of three great spaces (a quire and sanctuary with two transepts) that flow seamlessly into one another. It reminds me of the Norman crypt
chapel in Durham Castle (for the second time on this
voyage – that was my thought inside the grand but absurd monument to Kaiser Wilhelm in
Koblenz). You know you could pray here. There's a fourth room up some stairs where Ottonian electors, kings and bishops are
buried. It's breathtaking. It's beautiful. And it puts you in your place by
bringing you to your knees. Which is what a good church building should always
do (said J.L. Pearson, whose Truro Cathedral proves
his point).
Later, someone reports that they'd
overheard a Brit saying they didn't like the Cathedral because it was "a
bit too plain". "Who is that person?" I retort? "Bring them out
so that we may shoot them." "O they weren't from our ship" comes the quick reply.
Across the city the four towers of the
Cathedral stand "strong and stable" as if to say, never forget that
technology did not arrive with the Industrial Revolution. Our great cathedrals
called for cutting edge technology in their own day,
and this cathedral proves that its practitioners succeeded brilliantly. So our
day in Speyer has been of a piece. Which is both thought-provoking and
satisfying.
Sunday
Clear sky, warm sunshine. The landscape glides by as we sit on deck on this dreamy morning. We overtake a freighter called Promessa. So long is it and so tiny the difference in speed that it
takes half an hour. Children on board in the crew's
quarters at the stern give us a cheery wave. We pass Karlsruhe where there are
massive oil installations and power stations.
We get into the coach and drive up into
the Black Forest. This is an act of piety on my part: I have a clear memory of
a holiday in the Schwarzwald in 1952, which must make it my earliest of all. We
are in a hotel dining room. I can see fir trees
outside the window. My parents and at least two others (women I think) are
eating at table. But I am on the floor underneath the table playing with a toy
train. J thinks this is replete with Freudian symbolism (evergreens, being
alone in the presence of others etc). I know that we holidayed
there when I was two. We were also in Düsseldorf that year from where I have
another very primitive memory of being in bed in a garret while bells are
tolling in a church tower across the road.
The coach tour is allegedly to give us
the feel of the Schwarzwald. It is indeed very beautiful, the German mirror
image of the French Vosges on the other side of the Rhine that I got to know as
a student when I worked in Alsace. These wooded hills
feel steeper, less tamed, as if you would not be surprised to meet a wild boar
or a wolf or a bear here (all alleged, though the evidence is inconclusive).
And so we descend into "Rhinedale", cross the river and are in
Strasbourg and France. For years this has been one of
my favourite cities, though this banlieue near the
busy Port of Strasbourg where the ship is moored is new to me. Here at least,
when I look out of the cabin window, I see a working
riverine environment with not a cliché in sight. This authenticity is a relief
after all those cuckoo clocks.
Monday, 14 March 2016
In Praise of π
It was always going to be irresistible. When my daughter told me that today was a unique Pi Day 2016 (14 March, 3.14.16) I knew I would want to blog about it. Indeed, given the part mathematics has played in my life, I'm surprised I haven't blogged on it before.
I owe a lot to π. Not so much to the number itself, for all its irrational, transcendental qualities (those are technical mathematical terms by the way, not just the blogger's purple prose). But to what it symbolises and represents in the world of thought, in the structure of the universe, and not least in my own life.
For autobiography comes into things today. I can remember that even at a tender age I used to long to make sense of the arcane mathematical symbols that littered the books I pulled off the school library shelves: all those xs and ys and Σ signs and long swirly Ss which I can't do on this keyboard but which I later learned to know as symbols of integration, and dy/dx, and e and most of all, because it seemed to crop up everywhere, π.
I think I fell in love with maths when I finally got to understand what π stood for. Calculating a circle's circumference and area was where it all began of course. But as I went on to do A level maths, it seemed to me miraculous that this innocent Greek letter could work so hard. It featured in places where I least expected it such as working out the period of a pendulum or the movements of the planets or how the hours of daylight change as we travel through the year. And more and more surprises the deeper I went.
I went on to read maths at university. There I began to penetrate the mysteries of algebra, analysis, geometry, topology, number theory and formal logic. (From this some readers will deduce that my inclinations were very much on the 'pure' side of mathematics. I was never much good at 'applied' maths or statistics, though of course π makes plenty of appearances in those areas too.) I loved what I was studying. I loved mathematics for itself, its elegance and beauty, its endless capacity to model worlds we know about and worlds we can never know. I loved it because it seemed to draw me into the deep structures of the universe itself. Was it an art or a science? I used to wonder. I still do. Maybe it doesn't matter.
And I loved maths for how it was teaching me to think. There are various theories of what mathematics is in itself. Philosophers differ, for instance, about whether it has some 'eternal' (God-given?) existence outside ourselves, whether it is a product of the human mind and its patterns of thought, or whether it is an elaborate game played according to set rules or axioms that govern how we handle signs and formulae on the screen or page. But all agree that logic lies at the foundation of mathematics. And I was finding that my own habits of thinking and speaking, arguing and debating were being profoundly moulded by a desire at least to try to be rigorous.
I wish that after I graduated with a (not very distinguished) maths degree, I'd kept up my love of the subject. I never did apart from reading popular books on the subject from time to time - which I still do. However by then my vocation to be a priest was beginning to change the way I was thinking about my future. So I turned to theology and took a second degree in what used to be called 'the queen of sciences'. I loved that too. (Perhaps I'm lucky enough to be one of those insatiably curious people who can love almost anything that is interesting enough.) And I realised, when I started to write my first faltering essays, that I owed a huge amount to my mathematical studies.
When you study theology, you realise how easy it is to be careless about your assumptions and ways of working. Not all the textbooks were models of clear, disciplined, rigorous argument, I used to feel. As I said, maths taught me something of how to think. And as I now see, thought is so basic to who and what we are as human beings. There's much more to be said about Descartes' famous cogito ergo sum, 'I think, therefore I am'. There's more to human life than simply thinking. But he was on to something pretty important. And I reckon I started to glimpse it when I was studying maths as a schoolboy and a student. In that respect, π changed my life, if you'll allow the figure of speech.
My daughter is about to marry a high school maths teacher. He loves what he does, both the subject itself, and the art of teaching it and exciting young people in their journey of mathematical discovery. I was fortunate to have teachers who lit up mathematics for me too. It's true: you never forget a good teacher. The shortage of good maths teachers in our schools today is worrying. Mathematical literacy (which is more than simply numeracy) is one of the basic foundations of education. As Einstein put it, the point of education is not to impart facts but to teach us how to think. There's no better discipline than maths for helping us to do that. Maybe Pi Day is a chance not only to celebrate mathematics and mathematicians, but also to think about how we are going to train up the next generation of children for whom π will be as alluring as it once was for me.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

