Monday We have the day to ourselves in
Strasbourg. We start with the Cathedral, red and
magnificent rising sheer out of the haphazard old houses clustered around it.
Of exceptional beauty are the medieval windows, especiallythe Rose Window in the west walland the sculptures both outside
and in. The Pillar of
Angels is a highlight. The
south transept is always full of people but they are
there to enjoy the antics of the astronomical clock, a curiosity rather than a
thing of beauty. What they should be gazing rapturously at is this exquisite late gothic column, so
delicate, so touching, so humane. I also love the East Window. This is a fine piece of modern highly coloured glass set in the Romanesque apse. It was commissioned by the
Council of Europe and depicts the “Madonna of Strasbourg”. Above her head is the circle of the European Union’s gold stars. Surely this glowing window would melt the hardest of Brexit hearts?
However we are
unimpressed by the Cathedral's presentation of itself. Nobody minds their bag
being searched - that's just common sense nowadays. But half the Cathedral is
roped off or inaccessible, and you are tramlined around it by officious notices
telling you that this way, not that, is the
"sense de la visite". In particular, it is not possible to sit down
in the nave - always the best place to compose yourself in a great church to pray, meditate or orientate
yourself. But you can't do that here. All the pews are roped off on either side, so you go round
Ikea-wise. This is the last way you should treat a public space. The
contrast with Speyer is total. There you can walk where you want, sit where you
want, linger where you want. And that was in Germany!
Here there may be égalité(the ropes exclude us equally) but not much fraternité let alone liberté.
Jenny has a drink in a cafe in front of
the Cathedral while I climb up to the platform at the base of the spire. For €5
you get an extraordinary close up view of the gothic
fabric as you ascend and descend like an angel on this Jacob's Ladder. This
makes it worth the fee before you even glimpse the view from the top. The
filigree gothic opens up around you as you clamber up the spiral stairway, so you have the unnerving sight of distant roof
tops receding between your legs. The view of the nave pinnacles and flying
buttresses is an education in the construction of a late medieval cathedral.
The view is closed off by the Black Forest to the
east and the Vosges to the west. Although I've visited the Cathedral many
times, this is something I've never done and am glad late in life to have put
It is getting hot. We escape the fierce
sunshine and go to the Palais Rohan to visit the
Musée des Beaux Arts. This is another Strasbourg site I've never been to. It is
full of A-list paintings by
old masters - El Greco's beautiful Mater Dolorosa,
Tintoretto's Bearded Man, a Venetian view by Canaletto, a Giotto crucifixion
showing how he was beginning to appreciate
perspective, a couple of Zurbaráns (shouldn't these portraits be hanging in Auckland Castle?), Raphael's
Portrait of a Young Lady, a Dante Gabriel Rossetti (rather extraordinary to
find that here) and many others. Then there is the intriguing Belle
Strasbourgeoise by the city's portraitist Nicolas de
l'Argillière. And the 16th century Venetian painter Bernardo Strozzi's St
Anthony holding the Infant Jesus that captures the utter devotion of this young
man as he looks tenderly on the Holy Child. Our visit
is much enhanced by an audio guide (in English) that describes and interprets
the masterpieces. Well worth it.
We buy sandwiches and eat them in a
quiet little square where jets of water trace out parabolas underneath the trees. Schoolchildren run in doing a project on
Strasbourg. One girl hands me her question sheet and points to the question
about the trams. What colour are they? asks the sheet. I have peered closely at
the city's elegant trams and while many are silver,
some are green or yellow. So I hazard "yellow", explain I'm a
foreigner and apologise if I've got it wrong. My private view is that it's a
badly formed question. But it reminds me not to forget to mention the trams in
this blog. They arrived here in the 1990s, long after
I had stopped visiting Alsace regularly. Unlike some UK systems, this one goes
all over the city, even reaching out towards the dock where our ship is
berthed. It shows how forward looking this city is. But then, as the home of
the European Parliament, it perhaps felt it needed to
show its mettle and rise to some grand projet.
Which brings me to the map of Strasbourg
we were issued with on the ship. Not only is our berthing place not shown on
it, but a big star locates the European Parliament in
altogether the wrong place. We go in search of it near La Petite France where
the map shows it to be but all we find are quaint Alsatian black-and-white
houses, coffee shops and canals. And of course this great contemporary building
is several kilometres away from where we are. It's
ironic that of all sites worth visiting, this is the one that has got
misplaced. Clearly it is a mean Brexit plot specially designed for any Daily Express and Daily
Mail tourists who may be on board.
round the charming Petite
France and visit the Protestant St Thomas's
Church. The showpiece by a master of 18th century French heroic sculpture is a
huge memorial to a Marshall of France at the east end where the High altar
should be (and once was). More worthy, I suspect, is the great reformer Martin Bucer who was pastor of this church in the early
years of reform and who influenced Thomas Cranmer in his writing of the 1549
and 1552 liturgies. Touching too is a modest exhibition of art work focusing on
the "Two Brothers", i.e. not
simply the Prodigal Son but his loyal but grudging
elder brother too.
J goes back to the ship. I decide
to walk the towpath right round the island on which the city-centre of Strasbourg sits. This isn't as far
as it sounds as the historic centre is tightly enclosed by its rivers and canals.
But away from the busy streets and down by the
waterside it's a different, and cooler, world. There are a few walkers with
their dogs, and lovers in the shelter beneath the bridges, and young men
fishing, and an artist or two. But although I can hear the city with the incessant hum of traffic and the bells of its
trams and its churches, I am entirely alone among the trees and plants that
flourish down here in the lung that encloses this wonderful city.
After dinner we go up on deck to enjoy
the evening sunshine. The ship enters a lock, always a big event on a cruise.
You realise when passing through how big these cruise ships are and how much
water has to flow in and out. This lock is different from many others in that the gates slide up and down alongside the
road that crosses it. Which means that when we pass through we get a drenching
from the water still pouring off it. The captain has his umbrella ready. I have
left my iPad on a table so it gets a baptism too.
Luckily it was closed up so no harm is done.
Tuesday We wake up to the news of the Manchester bombings last night. A terrible
event. Somehow gliding down the Rhine on this beautiful morning accentuates the
horror of it, as if we exist in a detached world, a time capsule where we are
insulated from such things. I did not know if other
passengers have heard about it. No one seems to be talking about it at
breakfast or on deck. But social media have gone into overdrive about theManchester Arena. The Bishop and the Dean
have called on us to pray as best we can. The new mayor Andy Burnham tells us
that his city is strong and will come through this.
Heartachingly, people are tweeting about relatives and friends at the Arena,
wanting to know if they are safe. And all the while we are in this parallel
universe where the sun is shining and the river sparkles and people are happy to be on holiday. I feel utterly conflicted.
We pass Speyer again. The Cathedral is an
amazing and beautiful apparition on the skyline. We did
not see it in this way when we docked here. I watch it glide by and recede
round a curve in the river. It disappears like an old friend you fear you may
never see again. Truly one of the Romanesque wonders of the world. I would
gladly visit it once more, a hundred times more. It
is not just one of those sights/sites to tick off on my bucket list. Here is a
building that has extraordinary spiritual magnetism as well as aesthetic power.
I don't know when I last visited a church that has left such a deep impression apart from my beloved
Durham Cathedral. Conques maybe? Vézelay?
We pass an immense power plant on the
right bank. It is coal-fired
and belches a huge cloud of artificial cumulus into the atmosphere. It makes
for interesting photography, not least with foregrounds showing some of our
sunbathing fellow-travellers as if cruising
Soviet-style with the wonders of a planned economy and heavy industry to marvel
at from your sun bed. So this must be near Mannheim. It looks like a city is
having into view. On an artificial beach (if not a "seashore of endless worlds") children are playing.
We sail past Worms. On the skyline is
its Romanesque cathedral with four corner towers, just like Speyer. On a cruise
branded "Castles and Cathedrals of the Rhine", how can we not be
visiting this great church, said to be in the same
class as Speyer and Mainz? Given its place in the
history of Germany, not least in the Reformation era
thanks to its famous “Diet”, we should be docking here. I'd willingly sacrifice olde-worlde
black and white houses backed by vineyards for a look
at this city. (And while we are about it, why not sail
beyond Strasbourg to see Colmar and Neuf Brisach,
Vauban's great fortress
that surely qualifies under the "Castles" rubric of this tour? I
suppose because humankind cannot bear very many castles and cathedrals. So they will have to wait for another day.)
We arrive at Mainz. It is hot and sultry. The
riverside is full of sunbathers. We walk along it and head for the Cathedral
whose profile crowning the city we have admired as
the ship came in. It is vast, impressive, noble but - I'm afraid - unlovable.
It lacks atmosphere or much sense of spirituality, and doesn't come anywhere
near Speyer or Strasbourg. How do you define such
elusive qualities, you ask, this capacity of a
building or a painting or a piece of music to touch you in some deep place
within? I don't know, except that you recognise it when you see it. It would
take a Hans Urs von Balthazar, the 20th century catholic theologian who made a
study of these things, to explain the relationship
between a spiritual aesthetic and its ability to move you let alone "bring
you to your knees". I feel I need to move beyond "I like or even love
this" and "this touches and moves me" to an appreciation of what
is going on theologically when I experience deep
spiritual attraction or distaste.
Mainz Cathedral has eastern and western
sanctuaries, like at Nevers. I know that this is a very ancient arrangement but
also have a sense that double sanctuaries attenuate a sacred space rather than
focus it - for which is meant to be the true climax
of the building? Also like Nevers, we find modern stained glass of insistent -
and indifferent - quality. The monuments to the Archbishop-electors of Mainz
are very impressive, some medieval, some baroque. But you can hardly see them,
sosombre is the red sandstone
gloom. Actually, I like my cathedrals to be dark and mysterious ("Churches
are best to pray that have least light" says Milton). But that effect is enhanced no end with skilful lighting
to draw attention to detail, and then you feel the huge darkness looming all the more powerfully around. Here there is nothing to help you see
what there is to see. Any photography is a lost cause without a tripod.
Outside the Cathedral are two statues.
The first is of St Boniface, the Saxon missionary from Crediton
who was bishop here. The other is of Johannes Gutenberg, the inventor of printing, who was a son of Mainz and of
whom the city is intenselyproud. Mainz stuffed badly
through allied bombing, and it shows. This is one German city whose main thoroughfares, largely pedestrianised, could be
Coventry, Plymouth or Southampton. But as we head up the hill to see another
church, things become more tranquil. St Stefan's sits on top of a hill in the
old town and is the principal church of Mainz apart
from the Cathedral.
And here we find a sacred space that
feels entirely that - holy, loved, a church to pray in. St Stefan's is much
visited for its Chagall windows in the quire. They are truly magnificent:
colourful, playful, luminous, yet presenting serious
reflections on Old Testament themes. We can't get very close to them because
the quire is roped off (as it always is in French and German churches –as at
Strasbourg and Speyer, the
Cathedral had roped off large sections of the
building which are often where
the most interesting things are to be found). The rest of the church is
sensitively glazed in a translucent blue that sets off the Chagalls splendidly
without competing with them. There is much else to enjoy in this lovely church including medieval and modern sculptures, and a wonderful
On the way back to the ship we call in
at the Cathedral once again, not to visit the nave but to see the cloister.
Here the Cathedral redeems itself. It's a gorgeous space, every inch what a medieval cloister should be. There are trees,
shrubs and colourful flowers in the garth with a fountain in the middle. I
notice tombstones marking burials of Cathedral clergy. In the alleys, the
golden sunlight plays through the decorated tracery
throwing sculptures and reliefs into a most beautiful chiaroscuro, a gift for a
photographer. This is how I'd always envisaged Durham’s cloister should be, a place to linger in and be refreshed, a garden enclosed
within a city, a symbol of all that is lovely and redemptive
We sail on to Rüdesheim at the entrance
of the Rhine Gorge. Across the river is Bingen, where Hildegard came from. At
least six other big cruise
ships are already berthed here. We take a postprandial evening stroll
along the Rheinstrasse to the little town. It's world famous as a wine shrine;
apart from that its focus is tourism which it does to a spectacular degree.
About two million people come here each year. I wish this year that there had been two fewer - us. The river front is a strip
such as you would find at a seaside resort with down-market cafes, souvenir shops and entertainment of various
kinds. The famous main street is called the Drosselgasse and runs up the hill. Genuinely quaint and faux-quaint buildings jostle for
space along this exceedingly narrow gennel. It is crammed with souvenir shops, cafes and
restaurants, and also with people, for this is the Place to Be. Mercifully the
little train that scatters pedestrians across the
other streets in this town can't get up this one.
Every cliché in the book is here in this
self-conscious town that has sold its soul to us the tourists. Here is picture book Germany - black and white houses strewn across the town in playful chaos; vineyards stretching up the hillside with
dark forests beyond; fairy tale castles and turrets, church spires...and we all
fall for its seductions. But we are taken in if we do. It's not the real
Germany we're experiencing but a "Germany" that belong to fantasy, and which has been cynically exploited in order
to grow its tourist industry. It's not their fault - it's we the consumers who
drive the economy of this and every other theme park, whether it's Disney,
Cotswold villages or Sydney Harbour. Even cathedrals are not immune from this cheapening of our heritage. It is one of the most
intractable problems of our time.
We have tomorrow morning to spend in the
town. It may be a challenge to fill the hours. But we could try to be ethical
tourists who at least bring an attitude to the place that is capable of asking
questions and engaging in a conversation about what
tourism really is and how we stop it eroding the very thing we have come here
to experience and enjoy.